By Abraham Delleh-Wala
About the Author:
Abraham Delleh WALA is a Liberian with expertise in administration, compliance, security and corporate governance. He holds both Bachelor’s and a Master’s degree in Public Administration from the University of Liberia. He currently serves as an Adjunct Lecturer in the Department of Business and Public Administration at Margibi University, Margibi County, Republic of Liberia. Further, he serves as a Facilitator at the Institute of Climate Change and Health Research (ICCHR). As part of his research and comparative analysis of administration and public policy in Africa, he has traveled extensively throughout the region, including visits to Ghana, Sierra Leone, Guinea, Côte d’Ivoire, Togo, and the Benin Republic. He aspires to become a Lawyer so he can offer legal services to humanity.
Abstract
For a brief overview, the United Nations is an inter-governmental organization task to promote international corporations and to create and maintain international order. Most of the world’s leaders and organizations look up to the UN for creating global peace, security, basic needs and stabilization. Since its foundation, there has been many dynamic reforms and resolutions with overwhelming impact on the organization and the world as a whole. This research seeks to address the consequences and necessity of those changes.
Introduction
The United Nations replaced the League of Nations which had failed to prevent war between nations. Its present head office is located in New York, USA. The United Nations has six organs which are: the general assembly, the Security Council, the economic and social council, the trusteeship council, the international court of justice, and the secretariat. The present secretary general is Antonio Guterres. Now with 193 members, the organization’s structure still reflects the geopolitical circumstances at its founding. There are fifteen members of the Security Council, five of which are permanent and have the veto power. Its five permanent members are: China, France, The Russia Federation, United Kingdom and the United States of America. The remaining ten members are called non-permanent members and are elected on a two-year term basis by the General Assembly. The United Nations came into being after the devastation of the Second World War. For half a century the world organization has been tied to the power balance of 1945. Since its foundation in San Francisco in 1945, the United Nations has been undergoing significant and major transformation periodically (Martin et al, 2005). Some of those transformations stemmed from the initiation and implementation of proposals that had been an ongoing process and continues today. There still remain some indifferences and dissatisfaction in some of these proposals considering their advantages and disadvantages. Furthermore, some discrepancies lie within the organization in relation to the fairness of the election of the five permanent members. Research has revealed that two of the five permanent members, have been deemed as unqualified for their permanent seats in the office of the Security Council (Blum, 2005). In 1990 the United Nations collaborated with civil society and business in a quest to form new partners for a goal of shaping a new world. Today, businesses and civil societies still play a role in collaboration with the United Nations. The political and economic repercussions of the international demands is not in consonance to reflect the balance of power within the United Nations and as well as in commensuration with global politics.
Consequently, there is a need for reformation to reflect the balance of power in totality. The reform therefore has to address the question as to whether the global constellation at the turn of the millennium is still the same as when the organization was founded, and if not, in what respect has it changed. It goes without saying that a Charter which suits the interests of a small minority of member states (as those interests were defined in 1945) cannot be sacrosanct under circumstances in which the organization increasingly assumes a universal character with regard to its membership, in contrast to its founding period, when it was merely a minority organization of certain colonial powers and their allies in a peculiar constellation that had emerged from a world war. Common logical reasoning tells us that after the end of the bipolar system of the Cold War and since the emergence of new regional powers that did not yet exist as sovereign entities when the United Nations Organization was founded, a completely new scene of international actors has arisen, one which must be assessed with regard to each country’s right to be adequately represented in the international decision-making processes. While positive changes in any institution or organization should be beneficial, the United Nations dynamic reform proposals have some economic, political and social stance and/or advantages and disadvantages in relation to the effectiveness and fairness of the Security Council members, efficacy of drug control, global political and economic imbalances of the reform proposals, balances in weighing the reform proposals, and evaluation of the present necessity of the reform.
It has been stipulated that there is some ineffectiveness and unfairness in the election and the decision-making offices of the United Nations Security Council members. Furthermore, the United Nations reformation has incorporated non-governmental organizations (NGOs), religious leaders and other members of civil society who represent or engage better with disenfranchised people. In December 2004, the Secretary General then, Kofi Annan, appointed a panel to address threats, challenges and changes that the United Nations could experience in future years. The result of this panel’s report led to a reform to enlarge the members of the Security Council. The proposal of this reform was thus implemented. It was anticipated that the Security Council needed a larger credibility, legitimacy, and representation in order to meet the high demands of the organization. During that time, there was also a discrepancy and dissatisfaction concerning the level of power and qualification of the permanent members, especially in regards to critics of Great Britain and France (Blum, 2005). It was also stated that the ten non-permanent members are unnecessary as only nine votes for the permanent seat are required. The controversy also remains that the level of power endowed on the five permanent members is greater and the election of some of their members is unfair. Research has further shown that Germany and Japan are still advocating to form parts of the five permanent members seat for the justification of allocating more monetary funds to the organization. As an organization of governments designed to prevent war between states, it has struggled to address issues of civil and ethnic strife within countries. Since the end of the cold war, trends in conflict have shifted from international to intra-national conflicts; nations are no longer the defining framework for conflict. The United Nations Security Council, the UN’s enforcement tool, has had to cope with intra-state and non-state threats by expanding the jurisdiction of its authority, although some question the suitability of the UN intervening in internal conflict situations.
At the UN today, issues are still dealt with in the context of relations between nations, though they are often common problems within states. Many of the governments that make up the United Nations are dictatorial or authoritarian regimes that have been imposed by force, and do not reflect the interests of the majority of their people. As a result, not only Germany and France, but a sizable number of the world’s peoples feel they have no representation in the United Nations. Proposals have been made to reform the UN to give non-governmental organizations (NGOs), religious leaders and other members of civil society who represent or deal better with disenfranchised people, a greater role in the United Nations. Taking all these factors into due consideration, we realize that there is no true international legitimacy in the present global constellation. Any decision about international peace and security, especially on the basis of Chapter VII of the Charter, is determined by the interests of particular UN member states, which override the interests of the weaker states. The UN Charter with its provisions in favor of a strong Security Council that is to say, its permanent members – serves as a convenient cover for old-fashioned realpolitik, whether in the Gulf, in Somalia, and in former Yugoslavia. Because of the lack of mechanisms of democratic control in the Charter itself, the most powerful state is able in many instances to have its interests “canonized.” Smaller states are involuntarily reduced to the status of puppets that can do no more than endorse what has already been decided. Austria’s role as a non-permanent member of the Security Council in the period of the last Gulf War is a vivid example of this predicament. Vis-à-vis the overwhelming factual power of the leading “permanent” actors in the Security Council, there is for the smaller states or even regional groupings of states (such as the Arab League, the Organization of African Unity, or the Organization of the Islamic Conference) no margin to maneuver. This is particularly demonstrated by the peace process in the Middle East, where, since 1967, no Security Council enforcement measures have been imposed upon the occupying power in Palestine, while the authority of the Council on the basis of Chapter VII was excessively used to pacify the Islamic Gulf region with consequences that most of us are not yet aware of. We have seen that the present United Nations system reflects the power balance of an earlier era and imposes upon the rest of the world a “legitimacy” guaranteed by a few “constitutionally” privileged countries – whereby such privilege results from actual power, not from legal rights. Apart from this fact, the lack of democracy on the international level is also evidenced by the United Nations’ proven inability to do anything meaningful to bridge the gap between North and South in terms of economic conditions. The existing economic imbalances are not addressed by the UN Charter, which is no wonder if we take into consideration the fact that the Charter was drafted by the leading colonial powers of the forties. The “constitutional inequality” which was written into the Charter by those who privileged themselves as the “permanent members” is complemented by the economic inequality between North and South. No country of the South has the status of permanent member in the Security Council. The “haves” are not ready to share with the “have-nots” – whether with regard to (political, military) power or wealth. Sovereign equality, in the legal sense of the term, is denied to the non-permanent members of the Security Council; equality in a broader economic and political sense is furthermore denied by the economically powerful countries of the North to those of the South. Vague provisions in the UN Charter have allowed the Security Council (particularly since the collapse of the Soviet Union and the end of the East-West conflict) to gradually arrogate additional powers beyond its original mandate and in contradiction with general rules of international law. We have seen this in the adjudication of border disputes (as in the case of Iraq and Kuwait) and in the setting up of international tribunals (as in the cases of former Yugoslavia and Rwanda). All of this is clearly in violation of the principles of the separation of powers (so essential for the rule of law (and to the detriment of the status and competence of the International Court of Justice). The domineering nature of the Security Council’s role in the UN power equation which was designed to suit the Allied Powers of World War II – is even more serious and detrimental to global justice at a time when only one superpower determines the course of action. All of the above-mentioned forms of an unrestrained and uncontrolled exercise of power resemble the traditional system of government as represented by European absolutism. This kind of unrestricted rule is the direct result of a change in the balance of power since the end of the East-West conflict. The effective control of the only remaining superpower over the decision-making processes of the Security Council has led to an erosion of international legitimacy and has severely undermined the UN Charter in its basic claim of establishing an international order where peace and human rights prevail. Under the slogan of the “New World Order,” a policy of double standards has been introduced in the international arena, where interests prevail over rights of peoples and states. A striking example of this trend is the recent sanctions policy and practice of the Security Council. This factual situation reveals the basic weaknesses of the UN system with regard to the requirements of transnational democracy.
The reform in relation to drug consumption, control or enforcement has proven ineffective in many of the world’s countries. In 1998, the United Nations General Assembly special assembly agreed that all government wound reduce the production and consumption of drugs within the period of ten years, which has now elapsed. In review of this proposal, as a result of the interaction of epidemic forces, culture and economic development, the global demand of illicit drugs has now stabilized. In Europe and a few other countries, drug policy is becoming more tolerable but continues to be in serious effect in most of the world (Reuter, 2009). It has been stipulated that prevention, treatment and enforcement strategies have proven ineffective in the extent of drug use and addiction. Government is now focusing on reducing the damaging consequences of drug use and drug control versus preventive and enforcement strategies. There are three United Nations treaties that together form the international law framework of the global drug control regime: the Single Convention on Narcotic Drugs, 1961, as amended by the 1972 Protocol; the Convention on Psychotropic Substances, 1971, and the Convention Against Illicit Traffic in Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances, 1988. The purpose of these treaties is to establish internationally applicable control measures with the aim of ensuring that psychoactive substances are available for medical and scientific purposes, while preventing them from being diverted into illegal channels. The treaties also include general provisions on the trafficking and use of psychoactive substances. To understand how the drug-related treaties came about, we need to refer to the historical and political context at the time they were adopted and the international events that preceded them. The proposal to create an international legal framework governing psychoactive substances was an initiative of the United States that dates back to the start of the 20th century and has gone through several stages since then. In February 1909, amid growing concern about opium use in China, twelve countries met in Shanghai and set up the International Opium Commission to discuss the possibilities for imposing international controls on the opium trade for the first time. The delegates resolved, though without committing themselves, to put an end to the practice of smoking opium, restrict its use to medical purposes, and control its harmful by-products. No attempt was made at the time to apply criminal law in this regard. This was the background to the first International Opium Convention (The Hague, 1912). This and other later treaties negotiated by the League of Nations (predecessor to the United Nations, 1919-1946) were normative rather than prohibitive in nature and their objective was to curb the excesses of an unregulated system of free trade. This meant that they imposed restrictions on exports but did not make it obligatory to declare drug use or cultivation illegal, let alone make these activities a criminal offence. Thus, the provisions they established for opiates, cocaine and cannabis did not involve criminalizing either the substances themselves or their users or producers of their raw materials. This was the reason why the two most ‘prohibitionist’ countries at the time, the United States and China, withdrew from the negotiations that led to the 1925 International Opium Convention, because they considered its measures to be insufficiently restrictive. On that occasion, the United States was aiming to secure not just the prohibition of drugs, but a ban on the production and non-medical use of alcohol, attempting to reproduce on an international scale its alcohol prohibition regime that remained in force from 1920 to 1933. This attempt was thwarted because the United States did not have the support of the European colonial powers (France, Great Britain, Portugal and the Netherlands) whose overseas territories enjoyed a profitable monopoly on drugs (opium, morphine, heroin and cocaine) destined for the pharmaceutical market in Europe and the US. Emerging from the Second World War as the dominant political, economic and military power, the United States was then in a position to forge a new drug control regime (the 1946 Lake Success Protocol) and apply the necessary pressure to impose it on other countries in the setting of the United Nations. The political climate enabled the globalization of prohibitionist anti-drug ideals. The idea of having a Single Convention was once again an initiative of the United States, a country determined to impose a hard line on drugs on the rest of the world. The purpose of the 1961 United Nations Single Convention on Narcotic Drugs was to replace the previous international agreements that had been reached since the International Opium Convention in a not very systematic manner. It includes new provisions that did not appear in the previous treaties, and thus creates a unified, universal system of drug control. This system is clearly intolerant and prohibitionist concerning the production and supply of narcotic drugs, except for their production and supply for medical and scientific purposes. The 1961 Single Convention expanded existing control measures to cover the cultivation of plants from which narcotics are derived. These provisions placed an especially heavy burden on the traditional producer countries in Asia, Latin America and Africa where the cultivation and widespread traditional use of opium poppy, coca leaf and cannabis were concentrated at the time. The Single Convention set the target of abolishing traditional uses of opium within 15 years, and traditional uses of coca and cannabis within 25 years. Given that the Convention entered into force in December 1964, the 15-year period for gradually eliminating opium use came to an end in 1979, while the 25-year deadline for coca and cannabis expired in 1989. Traditional practices including religious use and the widespread “quasi medical” use of the three plants had to be abolished. The Single Convention created four lists or Schedules of controlled substances and established a process for including new substances in the Schedules without the need to modify the text of the treaty’s articles. The Convention’s four Schedules contain more than one hundred substances, which are classified according to the different degrees of control to which they must be subjected. (See: Schedule of the Single Convention on Narcotic Drugs of 1961 as amended by the 1972 Protocol, as at 25 September 2013). Some of the most controversial classifications in the Schedules are the inclusion of coca leaf in Schedule I and cannabis (cannabis and cannabis resin, and extracts and tinctures of cannabis) in Schedules I and IV. Schedule I contains the substances considered the most addictive and harmful. Schedule IV contains a small number of substances with “particularly dangerous properties” and with little or no therapeutic usefulness. With regard to Schedule IV narcotics in particular, Article 2, 5 (b) of the Convention says that “A Party shall, if in its opinion the prevailing conditions in its country render it the most appropriate means of protecting the public health and welfare, prohibit the production, manufacture, export and import of, trade in, possession or use of any such drug except for the amounts which may be necessary for medical and scientific research only.” As far as cohesive and consistent “international law enforcement” is concerned, sovereignty cannot be placed under a taboo any longer. Here, too, we are confronted with the inevitability of a World State concept (or that of a World Confederation) that does away with the traditional Souveränitätsanarchie, the “international anarchy among sovereign actors.” Apart from the question of the (political, economic, military) power of states, the international reality is determined by another factor that is often overlooked in the treatises on the restructuring of international organization: the factual power of transnational economic entities that often determine the governments’ bilateral and multilateral negotiations. One of the weaknesses of the theory of “liberal democracy” in the West is that these (not so hidden) economic players acting outside the official governmental framework are often ignored. They have acquired major importance at least for the shaping of North-South relations and for the industrialized world’s policies on international trade in general. In spite of their actual influence, they act completely outside any framework of transparent democratic procedures. Any reform of the international system has to tackle this issue of hidden economic power and its leverage on transnational decision-making. The review of balances of the reform then became necessary in 1996, at which time major comprehensive proposals to restructure the United Nations were presented and reviewed. These proposals were also consequences of some challenges that were encountered by the organization. Some of the challenges included civil conflicts within states, population growth, massive voluntary migrations, environmental degradation, economic justice, expanded concepts of human rights, and belief in the possibility and necessity of representative government (Russett, 1996). However, ten balances for weighing the said proposals were considered during that era of time in an attempt for substantiality.
- The Balance the Interest and Perspectives of States and those of Broad-based Non-governmental Organizations (NGO’s) and other Non-state Actors: It was concluded that majority of the participants derived from public sector backgrounds, giving valuable consideration to the state versus the organization. The proposal could then only become fruitful if they chose to travel the path of the truth while speaking the reality of power. This speaks to the fact where it becomes right, fair and unbiased to enable the power of leadership to adhere to the moral implications of the truth even it means harm to one’s personal interest.
- The Balance between the Preservation and Erosion of State Sovereignty: The United Nations, being an organization of sovereign states is neither a world government nor an assembly of peoples. Some elites and some of their citizens obviously, may want to retain sovereignty of the states they control. If the proposal fails to preserve or strengthen the state sovereignty, it may experience an unfruitful and unhappy reception from those having the power to enact the proposal.
- The Balance between Practicality and Vision: This simply deals with the ideology of setting realistic goals. The primary focus here is the question of what will states readily accept or how successful can the persuasion of the reform proposals be? This report calls for additional funding that are independent of political budgetary constraints under which most governments operate (Russett, 1996). Visions in this dimension could be somewhat impractical, yet it could also become necessary to make any reform worth pursuing.
- The Balance between Power (and effectiveness) and Legitimacy (or justice): In essence, nothing can be done without the capability or power and willingness to perform it. In the global arena, many United Nations activities must have the approval and usually the active participation and support of most of the powerful states in the system. Again, the Security Council cannot, given the veto, embark perform an operation against the wishes or approval of a permanent member. In the absence of adequate power, no action can be effective. It must also reflect the financial power of states essential to the organization’s fiscal health and particularly to its peace keeping operations. Germany, now being the world’s second largest contributor to the United Nations funds, if added to the state of permanent members, it becomes difficult to see how without adding some major less developed countries, it can retain legitimacy in the eyes of the great majority of UN member states. In turn, however, the more numerous and diverse the permanent members veto power, the more difficult it will become to act promptly and effectively when the world’s community need an action taken (Russett, 1996).
- The Balance between Particularity and Universality: The situation where a controversy stands between the respect for national and subnational cultural values mainly different priorities and concepts of human rights and the proclamation of the wild spread principle that there are universal human rights and underlined agreement as to what those rights entails.
- The Balance between Civil and Political Rights on one end and Economic Rights on the Other Hand: For some countries, especially the poor ones, economic (needs) comes first as civil and political rights are considered luxury that may be considered later if ever. Most rich countries are governed by democratic leaders and many poor ones by authoritarian leaders. Representative government can establish balanced and equitable economic development by equal distribution of income, political stability, and legitimate government with a restrained rule of law. There will possibly be a form of contraindication between some kinds of rights and others in particular instances.
- The Balance between Enforcement and Neutrality: The thought of an international organization empowered to protect the basic human rights obviously causes fear not only among those judged guilty in particular instances but also among the weak states everywhere and in all dimensions. However, it also presents the hope of individuals who are faced with vulnerability and oppression. In the arena of the United Nations traditional operations for peace and security, peace keeping with the consent of the parties were given the authority to shoot only in self-defense and were allowed to only maintain roles of being neutral.
- The Balance between Specificity and Plasticity of the Charter: The United Nations Charter has been a strong bargaining bone within the organization. It has proven to be a flexible tool in maintaining international peace and security. It is extremely difficult to end the Charter formally since amendments require ratification by two-thirds of the member states including approval by all five permanent members of the Security Council. The problem remains how to write a foundational document that will preserve the foundation while underpinning a structure that can expand, contrast and change its form and function in response to new and unforeseen power realities and challenges.
- The Balance between Coordination and Uniformity of Purpose and Diversity: The review of this balance becomes inevitable because a common criticism of the United Nations has been that of incoordination of its various units and specialized agencies. The result of their incoordination is the waste of already very limited resources and failure. It seems difficult and intolerable to have different organs of one body work at bureaucratic cross-purposes (Russett, 1996. p 268). In some aspects of economic development, the UN and the members of economic profession who advice on policies and procedures have yet to come up with a coherent and unified theory of economic development. The Independent Working Group’s proposal for a new Economic Council contains a tension that is most likely difficult to be avoided. Expecting very much is surely not desirable nor possible in a world of sovereign states. How and where the balance will be struck lies in the realm of a continuing political process that will always also reflect the competing claims of the balance of effectiveness and legitimacy.
- The Balance of Interests: Like any other instances of governance, the governance of the United Nations is a political process in which numerous interests exert claims and resist claims. Due to this fact, any reform proposal will have to entail something that will please almost everyone as well as something to offend almost everyone. As unreal as it may sound, the trick is to get the balance right, not in just a single reform proposal but in a package of proposals. No single reform recommendation can be considered in isolation of others, nor will any large package be put together without long and intense negotiation and debate around the world. The task of reforming and renewing the United Nations is a difficult but essential task.
In an evaluation of the reform and the global task of the United Nations, there still remains a need for a change as some of the organizational goals and that of the reform has yet to be met. Since its inception, there have been many calls for reform of the United Nations. However, in recent years — especially with the new millennium – calls have increased from nations and civil society alike that UN reform is necessary for its survival. Clearly, some reforms would require a change in the UN Charter. For some nations, such as the Permanent Five in the Security Council, even proposed additions to permanent UNSC membership are hotly debated. For others in civil society, the issue is that “rearranging the furniture” already in the house is nowhere near the kind of reform really required by the UN. Conceptually, some NGOs frame the issue whether the UN should be the premier intergovernmental association or the preeminent international peace organization. That question addresses whether the UN should exist for the benefit of the members states and their national interests, or, with the growth of non-state actors in contemporary international affairs, whether civil society at large, seen transnationally, is ultimately whom the UN should represent and protect. If the answer is the latter, that the UN should focus on peace and not the needs of nation-states per se, then its structure should change significantly to match the reality of a changing world in which peace and security are multidimensional, with increasing input from non-state actors as well as from traditional nation-states. In this view, if the UN cannot reform in the direction of securing peace under contemporary conditions, it eventually could be superseded by an entity that adapts itself appropriately to the times and pursues comprehensive global peace, inclusive of non-state actors, in particular, incorporating the religious dimension. Only this way, proponents say, can peace be secured for succeeding generations. Although reform of the General Assembly and Security Council are necessary, that will not be sufficient to enable the UN to fulfill its peace mandate. Advocates of this view note that former UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan himself, while still in office, recognized that “far-reaching institutional reforms” may be needed by the UN. Annan told the General Assembly on September 23, 2003: Excellencies, we have come to a fork in the road. This may be a moment no less decisive than 1945 itself, when the United Nations was founded. At that time, a group of far-sighted leaders – were determined to make the second half of the twentieth century different from the first half. They saw that the human race had only one world to live in, and that unless it managed its affairs prudently, all human beings may perish. So, they drew up rules to govern international behavior, and founded a network of institutions, with the United Nations at its center in which the peoples of the world could work together for the common good. Now we must decide whether it is possible to continue on the basis agreed then, or whether radical changes are needed. And we must not shy away from questions about the adequacy, and effectiveness, of the rules and instruments at our disposal.
Politicization of the United Nations
Self-policing has been difficult at times for the UN. The nature of the General Assembly structure, with one vote per nation regardless of the size or qualifications of nations, has led to politicization of well-intended efforts. For example, the prior inclusion on the now-defunct UN Commission on Human Rights of such nations as Sudan, Cuba and Libya, which demonstrably have abysmal human rights records, and Libya’s chairmanship of that commission, essentially stymied much human rights activity and made the commission itself illegitimate. The commission was replaced in 2006 by the UN Human Rights Council The issues of the UN’s failure to protect security and politicization put before the world the more difficult issue of how to effect change. The underlying questions still need to be looked at more seriously and responded to through international action:
- Is the process of change more effective through inclusion or exclusion?
- Do punishment and exclusion work or do alternate ways need to be found to “bring into line” those nations and leaders who scoff at international pressure?
- Should we be appealing to humanity’s higher capacities by focusing on ideals sought and how to get there rather than digging again through problems and ascribing blame?
- What is the key methodology for the UN in its pursuit of peace?
- What resources are currently underutilized and ignored that need to be understood, included and strengthened?
The nature of the above questions, highlighted by NGOs seeking more radical UN reform, point the way to solutions that include consideration of morality, ethics and the practical benefits of utilizing the moral authority of religions for peace.
Financial Waste and Scandals
Lack of checks and balances and transparency within the UN have led to financial waste and scandals. An example is the Oil-for-Food Programme established by the UN in 1996 and terminated in late 2003. It was intended to allow Iraq to sell oil on the world market in exchange for food, medicine and other humanitarian needs of ordinary Iraqis, who were adversely affected by international economic sanctions placed on the government. The goal of the sanctions was to prevent the Iraqi government from rebuilding its military in the wake of the first Gulf War. The Oil-for-Food Programme was curtailed amidst allegations of widespread abuse and corruption; its director, Benon Sevan of Cyprus, was first suspended, then resigned from the United Nations after an interim progress report of an UN-sponsored investigatory panel led by Paul Volcker concluded that Sevan had accepted bribes from the former Iraqi regime and recommended his UN immunity be lifted to allow for a criminal investigation. Under UN auspices, over $65 billion worth of Iraqi oil was sold on the world market. Officially, about $46 billion was used for humanitarian needs, with additional revenue paying Gulf War reparations through a compensation fund, supporting UN administrative and operational costs for the program, and paying costs for the weapons inspection program. Also implicated in the scandal was then-UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan, whose son, Kojo, was accused of having benefited from illegally procured UN Oil-for-Food contracts on behalf of a Swiss company.
The UN in Popular Culture
The existence of the UN as an over-arching global governmental organization has prompted many ideas about world government and world democracy. The UN is also often the subject of conspiracy theories, particularly attributed to the right, who maintain international elites aim to use the UN to effect global dictatorship. Also implicated in the scandal was then-UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan, whose son, Kojo, was accused of having benefited from illegally-procured UN Oil-for-Food contracts on behalf of a Swiss company. An educational activity, the Model United Nations, has grown popular in schools worldwide. Model UN programs have students simulate (usually) a body in the United Nations system, like the General Assembly, Security Council, the Economic and Social Council, the Economic and Finance Committee of the General Assembly, or the Executive Committee of UNICEF, to help them develop skills in debate and diplomacy. The United Nations has been depicted in several feature films. In the 1958 movie North by Northwest, director Alfred Hitchcock wanted to film in the UN, but did not receive permission; footage was secretly taken and UN facilities recreated on a sound stage. The 2005 film, The Interpreter, directed by Sydney Pollack, was the first movie permitted to be filmed on location inside the United Nations, in an effort to broaden international awareness of the United Nations.
A Forum of State Leaders
As a forum for governments, many people feel the UN supports regimes, not people. In many nations, dictators represent only their own self-interest, or the interest of their ethnic group. Decisions that support such regimes are often viewed by oppressed peoples as collusion by the UN in oppression. In this view, while the organization can stand for international human rights in theory, its structure actually supports human rights violations in practice. Proposals for reform include increased recognition of NGOs and civil society, and parallel organs like the previously discussed interreligious council that would speak on behalf of the dispossessed and equal opportunity and justice for all people.
Method of Representation
Representation is a major problem for the UN. First, many member states do not feel that they are properly represented on the Security Council or in the General Assembly. Second, many peoples throughout the world do not feel they are represented at the UN.
Security Council
The UN Security Council represents only 15 of the 193 member states, and among those 15, five have permanent membership and veto power. Most states feel they do not have a voice on the Security Council, the only UN organ with real military and police power to enforce its decisions. As the world power structure at the time of the UN founding recedes into the background, its structure decreasingly reflects world power realities. Many proposals to reform the Security Council have been offered, including regional representation, eliminating the veto power and permanent status of the five members, and increasing the size of the Security Council. There is a strong feeling that Japan (and perhaps India and Brazil) should become permanent members, but at the P5’s insistence, without veto power. What is attempted to describe here are the basic features of a “New World Order” of transnational democracy as distinct from the “Old World Order” of superpower rule. If the international community is serious about the democratization of the United Nations, then one must abandon the exclusionary character of the historical anti-Axis alliance of the Second World War (which undoubtedly was of anti-totalitarian nature and had its moral justification in the particular historical constellation) in favor of a truly universal organization that encompasses all nations and regions in fair and balanced representation. Only if the “We the peoples” in the Charter’s Preamble is taken seriously and if we distance ourselves from the étatist paradigm of an absolutely posited national sovereignty (as incorporated in the traditional concept of the nation-state) will a new beginning be possible, in the sense of partnership and peaceful co-operation. Inter-state democracy can only be based on such a reorientation of the doctrine of international relations away from the assumptions of the realist doctrine. In summing up our very provisional sketch of an alternative United Nations system that revolves around the paradigm of transnational democracy, we would like to point to the following basic requirements:
- The democratization of relations between states requires a fundamental change in basic concepts of international law such as the related concepts of national sovereignty and of interference in the internal affairs of other states. Sovereignty, which in its traditional étatist conception is linked to an abstract state entity, makes the existing imbalances we have referred to her even larger and makes democratic partnership between states even more elusive. Sovereignty must be redefined with regard to the sovereign rights of the citizen that are the foundation of every legitimate political entity.
- Acknowledging this is the only way to democratically solve the problem of inequality of sovereign member states of the United Nations, in which one state represents the interests of one thousand citizens and another state represents the interests of one billion, but in which both presently enjoy the same one vote in the General Assembly of UN member states. In the present imbalanced situation in the UN system, this amounts to a kind of discrimination, i.e. of “weighted voting” in the form of the one state-one vote formula, in favor of the less populated states and at the expense of the vast majority of mankind. This inequality, that particularly intensifies the tensions between the countries of the North and of the South, has to be compensated – as we propose in this brief sketch of genuine democratic reform – through a kind of weighted voting-formula which takes into account the population size of each member state. (As we stated earlier, the present General Assembly fits into the new system only as a Second Chamber in the form of a Senate, granting minority representation to the smaller states.) The normative requirements of such “weighted voting” in the international decision-making bodies can best be administered (as we have outlined above).
a. Through a balanced regional representation in the Security Council (whereby the seats allocated to each region on a permanent basis rotate among the members of the regional group), and
b. Through the establishment of an International Peoples’ Assembly as the First Chamber in this new UN system. In this First Chamber, which would be similar in structure and competence to the European Parliament, the number of deputies of each country – or group of countries in the case of smaller states – would be proportional to the actual population size. The protection of “minority rights” of smaller states can best be assured in such a system with a two-chamber model, whereby the General Assembly would serve as the Second Chamber.
The democratization of relations between states requires the introduction of a genuine separation of powers between the two envisaged world chambers which together comprise “legislative” authority, the executive power represented by the Security Council, and the judicial authority represented by the World Court. A new democratic Charter of the United Nations would have to define the role of the “International Peoples’ Assembly” – the First Chamber – in such a way that basic competencies presently reserved for the Security Council would be given to the peoples’ delegates. It would be totally impossible to simply transfer the role and competencies of the presently existing General Assembly to such a new Peoples’ Assembly. Such an Assembly should above all be able to pass resolutions that are binding upon all member states (including the members of the Security Council), whereby the Council’s role would be to enforce these resolutions. The authoritarian – and in a certain sense even totalitarian – structure of the present Security Council, in which legislative, executive and judiciary powers de facto coincide, cannot be tolerated in an alternative international system based on the paradigm of democracy. The dangerous development in the present “new” world order results precisely from this lack of the separation of powers in the UN system, in which the Security Council – since the collapse of the bipolar power system of the post-war era – has arrogated more and more powers on behalf of its leading actor, the United States. Meeting an outcome for a change institutes the need to adhere to policies and suggestions for change that were or are being cited by organizational branches. One ongoing debate has involved world governance in general. Historically, there have been three basic conceptions of international organization:
Federalism: This view advocates some degree of world government, imposed from the top down. The UN would act like a state, with the power to pass and enforce laws and to tax. This view is promoted by Citizens for Global Solutions (formerly the World Federalists) and articulated in the book World Peace through World Law by Grenville Clark and Louis B. Sohn. There has been much fear that a world government would trump national sovereignty and become a world tyranny.
Functionalism: This view believes that certain functional activities need international cooperation and standardization; for example, international aviation, international postal delivery and an international environmental protection agency. Ernst Haas’s Beyond the Nation-State: Functionalism and International Organization (ISBN 0804701873) elaborates this view. Many of the specialized UN agencies, like WHO, operate in this way.
Transnationalism: This view maintains that world organization will develop from the bottom up through the development of a world culture based on exchanges and transactions as people of different countries engage in commerce, travel, and forms of interaction. This view was articulated by Robert O. Keohane and Joseph S. Nye in Power and Interdependence: World Politics in Transition (ISBN 0316489360).
Conclusion
Since its inception, there have been many calls for reform of the United Nations. However, in recent years, especially with the new millennium, calls have increased from nations and civil society alike that UN reform is necessary for its survival. Clearly, some reforms would require a change in the UN Charter. For some nations, such as the Permanent Five in the Security Council, even proposed additions to permanent UNSC membership are hotly debated. For others in civil society, the issue is that “rearranging the furniture” already in the house is nowhere near the kind of reform really required by the UN. Conceptually, some NGOs frame the issue whether the UN should be the premier intergovernmental association or the preeminent international peace organization. That question addresses whether the UN should exist for the benefit of the members states and their national interests, or, with the growth of non-state actors in contemporary international affairs, whether civil society at large, seen transnationally, is ultimately whom the UN should represent and protect. If the answer is the latter, that the UN should focus on peace and not the needs of nation-states per se, then its structure should change significantly to match the reality of a changing world in which peace and security are multidimensional, with increasing input from non-state actors as well as from traditional nation-states. In this view, if the UN cannot reform in the direction of securing peace under contemporary conditions, it eventually could be superseded by an entity that adapts itself appropriately to the times and pursues comprehensive global peace, inclusive of non-state actors, in particular, incorporating the religious dimension. Only this way, proponents say, can peace be secured for succeeding generations. Although reform of the General Assembly and Security Council are necessary, that will not be sufficient to enable the UN to fulfill its peace mandate. Advocates of this view note that former UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan himself, while still in office, recognized that “far-reaching institutional reforms” may be needed by the UN. Annan told the General Assembly on September 23, 2003: Excellencies, we have come to a fork in the road. This may be a moment no less decisive than 1945 itself, when the United Nations was founded. At that time, a group of far-sighted leaders were determined to make the second half of the twentieth century different from the first half. They saw that the human race had only one world to live in, and that unless it managed its affairs prudently, all human beings may perish. So, they drew up rules to govern international behavior, and founded a network of institutions, with the United Nations at its center, in which the peoples of the world could work together for the common good. Now we must decide whether it is possible to continue on the basis agreed then, or whether radical changes are needed. And we must not shy away from questions about the adequacy, and effectiveness, of the rules and instruments at our disposal. He repeatedly urged members to seize a “once-in-a-generation opportunity” to reform the UN, or decisions a


